Sugarplums and Teas

403 Bank Barn Lane
Lancaster, PA 17602

Indulge Your Sweet Tooth!

Pastry delights for the senses. Even though we are a Tea Room, we also have coffees, and specialty drinks like smoothies and the forever-favorite hot chocolate! Need a special gift for someone who loves tea and tea accessories? We may have what you need!

Here’s a Few Favorite Treats:

Chocolate Amaretto Cake
Chocolate Soaked with Amaretto iced with French Buttercream & coated with Chocolate Ganache

Linzer Torte
A hazelnut cinnamon crust filled with raspberry marmalade

Fresh Fruit Tart
Shortbread pastry crust filled with Vanilla cream decorated with an array of fruits (Seasonal)

Chocolate Truffle Cake
A single layer of dense chocolate Iced with chocolate glaze

We make many varieties of New York Style cheesecake. Please ask about feature flavors

Flaky pastry with an almond filling. Specialty of the town of Pithiviers, France

Carrot Cake
A light spice cake loaded with raisins, pineapple, and walnuts, covered with a cream cheese frosting

Black Forrest Cake
Moist chocolate cake soaked with kirsch and filled with fresh cherry filling, topped with shaven chocolate

Fromage & Fruit Cake
Yellow cake with a light cream cheese filling and your choice of fresh strawberries, pineapple, or mandarin oranges

German Chocolate Torte
A dark chocolate cake layered with a coconut pecan filling and iced in chocolate buttercream

Coconut Cake
A coconut pound cake soaked in coconut syrup. Rich!

Decorated Cakes and Pastries for Birthdays, Weddings, or Any Occasion

We love the laughter, smiles and the tears of joy from adults and kids alike. And the best part is that we get to create tasty, decorated cakes and pastries that fit perfectly into the occasion. Our chefs at Sugarplums and Teas not only have fabulous creations of their own, but we also have fun working with the ideas that our clients have thought about. The sky is the limit!

Having the party at home or some other location? That’s perfectly fine. Just know that Sugarplums and Teas also takes reservations for parties up to 36 persons inside our Tea Rooms.  Please contact us for availability.

Cookies, Cupcakes and Tasty Pastries

The aroma of fresh baked cookies, cupcakes and a variety of tasty pastries fills our Tea Room. Since our selection varies each day, you have the opportunity to sip your tea and excite your palate with a different pastry each time you visit Sugarplums and Teas.

What do your taste buds crave today? Cookies, scones, tarts, parfaits? Give us a call and we’ll let you know what we’ve baked up this morning!

 Pastries To Go… Home… Office… Parties

Need pastries to satisfy you family, coworkers or friends? Place an order with us and we’ll create a tray of delights just for you.

Here’s Some Selections To Consider:

Pastry Tray

Trays include a collection of pastries such as: 

  • Mini Cheesecake
  • Brownie Bites
  • Cream Puffs
  • Black Forest
  • Fruit Tarts
  • Lemon Bars
  • Chocolate Raspberry Fromage Cups
  • Peanut Butter Delights

Brunch / Luncheon Items

  • Raspberry White Chocolate Brownies
  • Lemon Poppyseed Cake
  • Cupcakes
  •  Muffins
  • Toffee Bars
  • Sweet and/or Savory Scones
  • Fruit Tart


  • Chocolate Chip
  • Peanut Butter
  • Cranberry Oatmeal
  • Lemon Poppy


  • Chocolate Chip
  • White Chocolate Chip
  • Lemon Poppy
  • Cinnamon Raisin
  • Pumpkin
  • Vanilla
  • Coconut


  • Cappuccino
  • Blondies
  • Peanut Butter

Gifts for Someone Special

In addition to over 100 loose teas, we also carry gifts and accessories. Featured in our shop are a variety of individual tea pots, tea sets, tea cups, tiered serving trays and platters in a large selection of colors and styles. All our individual tea pots have stainless steel tea infusers for hassle free brewing. We also have seasonal items and gift for you to shop! Have a special occasion to celebrate? Let us create a custom gift basket for you!