Sugarplums and Teas

403 Bank Barn Lane
Lancaster, PA 17602

Event Catering in Lancaster County. Small Parties, or Large Gatherings

Let Sugarplums & Teas take the stress out of your entertaining. We provide complete catering service in Lancaster County…. and you may choose to pick it up from our Tea Room location, or we can deliver & serve in style. 

Hors D’oeuvres, Salads, Sandwiches, and Delicious Desserts

Choose from a wide selection and we’ll create an array of tasty delights for any occasion. We can even customize the presentation of the catered items to a themed event – a birthday, wedding, retirement, or even a sporting activity.

Cold Hors D’oeuvres

Fruit Tray…with Dip

Small (serves 10-15) $40.00
Large (serves 20-30) $50.00

Cheese Tray

Small (serves 10-15) $ 35.00
Large (serves 25-30) $ 50.00

Vegetable Tray

Small (serves 10-15) $ 40.00
Large (serves 20-30) $ 48.00


w /fried pita chips $ 25.00

Cucumber Cups

(30 per tray) $ 26.00

Chicken Caprese Kabobs

(each) $ 2.25

Steamed Shrimp

(50 pc) Market Price – Please Ask

Antipasto Platter

Small (serves 10-15) $ 50.00
Large (serves 20-30) $ 70.00


w / fried pita chips $ 29.95

Homemade Fresh Salsa
w / homemade chips $ 24.95


w / crostini $ 19.95



Confetti Bean Caviar
w / homemade chips $ 24.95

Hot Hors D’oeuvres

Mini Quiches

Cheese, Ham or Spinach
(30 per tray) $ 32.00

Bacon Wrapped Hot Dog Bites

(35 per tray) $ 30.00

Chicken Ricotta Puffs

(30 per tray) $ 30.00

Honey Barbecue Meatballs

(40 per tray) $ 30.00

Swedish Meatballs

(40 per tray) $ 30.00

Mini Marinara Meatballs

(40 per tray) $ 30.00

Chicken Tenders

(30 per tray) $ 30.00

Chicken Satay Kabobs

(30 per tray) $ 35.00

Mini Crab Cakes

(25 per tray) Market

Crab Dip

(Container Size) Market Price – Please Ask

Meatball Marinara Puffs

(30 per tray) $ 30.00

Artichoke Dip

w/ fried pita chips $ 29.95

Spinach Dip

w/ fried pita chips $ 29.95

Asparagus Wrapped with Bacon

(each) $ 2.00

Spinach Pie

(Half Sheet Tray) $ 49.95

Stuffed Mushrooms

(each) $ 1.25

Sin Dip

(Container Size) $ 29.95

Sausage Bread

(Loaf) $ 14.95

Spinach Puffs

(30 per tray) $ 25.95

Main Courses

Sausage and Peppers:

Hot and/or mild Italian sausage mixed with green peppers and onions roasted with Italian spices, garlic and olive oil.

Eggplant Rollitini

Thinly sliced eggplant breaded and flash fried then rolled with ham and a blend of Italian cheeses, toped with marinara and mozzarella and baked.

Meatballs and Pasta

Homemade Meatballs slow cooked in marinara served with the pasta of choice.

Stuffed Pepper Casserole

Green peppers layered with seasoned meat, rice and tomato sauce topped with cheese and baked.

Chicken Marsala

Thinly sliced chicken sauteed with capers, mushrooms in a light brown marsala gravy.

Lemon Chicken

Thinly sliced chicken flash fried and covered in a tart lemon and caper sauce.

Chicken Parmesan

Fried Italian chicken cutlet layered with marinara and a blend of cheeses.

Swedish Meatballs

Small bit size meatballs slow cooked in a thick brown gravy served over buttery egg noodles.


Thinly sliced beef wrapped with ham and cheeses and baked in homemade marinara sauce.

Vegetable Penne

Penne pasta tossed with seasonal veggies, garlic, white wine and parmesan cheese.


Meat or veggie. Simple classic Delicious.